There
are two reasons to buy a car: for practical purposes and passionate
pursuits. Sure, there can sometimes be a hybrid of the two (think Dodge
Charger Hellcat), but nobody buys a minivan for a passionate pursuit.
The 2016 Honda Odyssey and 2016
Kia Sedona, though, could succeed in making you more passionate about minivans.
Typically,
you purchase these minivans for practical reasons because you’re either
hauling a family or you’re an older buyer who likes their practicality,
seating position, and roominess. Just because they’re practical,
doesn’t mean manufacturers haven’t been busy dressing them up and
loading them with options.
In spite of their sagging
popularity—now that Boomers are past the child-rearing stage—minivans
are still a relevant part of the marketplace. Through Dec. 1, Honda sold
almost 116,000 Odysseys. Kia has sold about 35,500 Sedonas in the same
time period. That represents about 8 percent of Honda sales and 6
percent of Kia sales.
I’ve recently spent time driving
both the Sedona and the Odyssey. Consider the Sedona the upstart and the
Odyssey the grand dame of minivans. Which is going to be your
preference? The numbers help tell the story.
The 2016
Honda Odyssey is a lower, wider vehicle than the 2016 Kia Sedona by an
inch or two in various places. The Sedona has an inch more wheelbase
space.
Both minivans have good, tested engines under
the hood. The 3.5-liter, Honda V6 has 248 horsepower while the 3.3-liter
V6 in the Sedona produces 260 horsepower. It’s a toss-up when it comes
to acceleration because both have similar torque numbers: the Odyssey at
250 lb. ft. and the Sedona at 248 lb. ft. Neither is going to blister
through its 0-60 times but both have lots of pep for highway on-ramps
and any passing situation. Both can comfortably cruise forever at 75
mph.
When it comes to driving, though, the Sedona wins
hands down. It feels more engaging and responsive. It was my feeling on
an extended drive during its media introduction and after a week behind
the wheel that this is a vehicle I like driving. After a week behind the
wheel of the Odyssey, however, it felt like just basic transportation.
The
Odyssey is much better at 19 mpg city and a whopping 28 mpg highway for
a combined 22 mpg. The Sedona’s fuel economy numbers are hard to
overcome from a practical perspective.
When it comes to
safety, consider this a tie between the two. All Sedonas and Odysseys
are equipped with standard safety features such as a vehicle full of
airbags, electronic stability control, traction control system, brake
assist system, hill-start assist control, electronic brake force
distribution, and antilock braking system. The Sedona does have
additional technologies such as rollover mitigation and cornering brake
control for improved dynamic control.
Exterior design
is a subjective issue. The Sedona to my eye is the more appealing. It’s
more of a head-turner. The Odyssey continues to look dowdy to me.
On
the interior, the HondaVac is a great feature. The dry vacuum system
has a hose that can reach the length of the interior. It works better
than a handheld vacuum. Two separate head attachments expand
versatility, while a removable debris canister and replaceable filter
bag make maintaining the vacuum easy.
The
Sedona offers
standard second-row Slide-N-Stow seating. It slides and folds upright
to allow for on-the-go cargo hauling along with a standard third-row,
split-folding 60/40 bench that retracts seamlessly into the rear cargo
floor. (It’s really simple to use, and I don’t follow directions well.)
Pricing
is going to be fairly comparable between the two models, depending on
your wants and needs. I drove the top-of-the-line Sedona SXL, which is
priced at $44,690 with all the bells and whistles. The
middle-of-the-line Sedona EX costs $33,595. The 2016 Honda Odyssey SE
costs $34,255. Consider it the middle of the Odyssey pack. The top
Odyssey has a price of $45,630.
Honda Odyssey SE
THE BASICS
Price, base (with destination): $34,255. Fuel economy: 19 city/28 highway/22 combined. Drivetrain: 3.5-liter, V6. Body: Minivan.
THE SPECIFICS
Horsepower:
248 @ 5,700 rpm. Torque: 250 @ 4,800 rpm. Overall length: 202.9 in.
Wheelbase: 118.1 in. Height: 68.4 in. Width: 79.2 in. Curb weight: 4,528
lbs.
THE GOOD
Fuel economy numbers are strong for the Odyssey.
THE BAD
The Odyssey isn’t a very engaging minivan to drive. It plods along like the Point A to Point B vehicle that it’s supposed to be.
Kia Sedona SXL
THE BASICS
Price, base (with destination): $40,795. Fuel economy: 17 city/22 highway/19 combined. Drivetrain: 3.3-liter, V6. Body: Minivan.
THE SPECIFICS
Horsepower:
276 @ 6,000 rpm. Torque: 248 @ 5,200 rpm. Overall length: 201.4 in.
Wheelbase: 120.5 in. Height: 69.1 in. Width: 78.1 in. Curb weight: 4,656
lbs.
THE GOOD
The Kia Sedona wins the passionate contest. It’s a much better looking minivan inside and out.
THE BAD
Fuel economy is disappointing at a combined 19 mpg. That’s not a good number for a family watching its budget.
THE BOTTOM LINE
Minivans mean different things to different people. Want a little zing in your drive? The Sedona is the better choice.